Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days | Logo

Fine Dining on the North Shore of Lake Puckaway

,
This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.
This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.
Menu

Our Food and Beverage Menu

- Dine-In, Carryout & Outside Seating

- Weekly Specials

- Live Entertainment

This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.

Hours:

This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.

Delicious Steaks, Seafood Specialties and More

If you're in the mood for some appetizing food, Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days is the place to visit. We're a fine dining restaurant in Montello, WI offering you the best in grilled specialties - from prime ribs and steaks to pork chops.


You'll love our steaks prepared using USDA Choice hand-cut flame-broiled meat. Pair your main course with your choice of appetizer and beverage and you're all set for a great dining experience, whether in the comfort of your home or at our restaurant.


So, browse through our menu to see what you'd like to try when you come down to our restaurant. You'll be pleased to know that we offer a kids' menu and senior menu as well.


Call us if you want to reserve your table or stop by our restaurant today. Takeout and catering services are provided!

Menu

*MIKE'S SPECIALTY PRIME RIB

Served Saturday Only
Petite Cut
12oz.
$23.95
Queen Cut
16oz.
$27.95
King Cut
24oz.
$36.95
Super Cut
36oz.
$52.95

*STEAKS

USDA Choice Hand Cut - Flamed Broiled
20oz. Bone-in Ribeye

New

$35.95
T-Bone 16oz.
Always a favorite.
$25.95
Ribeye 16oz.
Tender and juicy.
$29.95
Boneless Top Sirloin 16oz.
Mike's favorite.
$26.95
Filet Mignon 8oz.
Always tender.
$34.95
Sirloin 8oz. and 4 Jumbo Fantail Shrimp
Steak and shrimp.
$24.95
Filet 8oz. and Rock Lobstertail 8oz.
Something special.
$59.95
Add 3 Breaded Jumbo Shrimp
$8.95
Side Order Mushrooms and Onions
$4.95
Soup and Full Salad Bar Only
$9.95

FROM THE SEA

Deep Fried Alaskan Cod
$16.95
Broiled Icelandic Cod
$17.95
Deep Fried Walleye
$17.95
Breaded (8) Jumbo Fantail Shrimp
$16.95

All Dinners include Choice of Potato, Soup, and Salad Bar.

$2.00 Charge for Splitting Dinners

APPETIZERS

Large Crinkle Cut Fries
$3.50
Large Brew City Fries
$4.50
Onion Rings (10)
$6.50
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
$6.50
Cheeseballs (15)
$6.50
Pretzel Bites (12)
$6.50
Breaded Mushrooms (12)
$6.50
Breaded Cauliflower (12)
$6.50
Cheddar Cheese Poppers (6)
$6.50
Cream Cheese Poppers (6)
$6.50
Pickle Fries
$6.50
Combo

4 onion rings, 4 breaded mushrooms, 4 breaded cauliflower, 4 cheeseballs, 2 poppers, 2 mozzarella sticks, 4 mini tacos, plus fries.

$12.95
Brakebush Chicken Wings (8)
$7.95
Brakebush Tender Strips (5)
$7.25
Shrimp Basket with Fries
$8.95
Beer Battered Shrimp (15) with Fries
$9.95
Eggrolls
$1.50 each / 3 for $4.00
Mini Tacos (12)
$6.50
Side Salad
$4.95
Chicken Parmesan Salad

One sauce per order included. Additional or extra sauces - $0.25 each.

$8.95

BAR ONLY

Chips-N-Salsa
$5.95
Nachos-N-Cheese
$6.95
Extra Jalapeños
$0.25

HOMEMADE PIZZAS - BUILD YOUR OWN

12 Inch

Additional Toppings - $1.00 Each

$11.00
16 Inch

Additional Toppings - $1.25 Each

$14.00
Toppings

Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Onion, Sausage, Pepperoni, Green Olives, Black Olives, Canadian Bacon, Jalapeños, Pineapple

*OTHER SPECIALTIES

*Mike's Famous Baby Back Ribs
1/2 Rack $17.95 / Full Rack $24.95
*Ribs and Chicken
1/2 rack of ribs and 2 pc. broasted chicken.
$21.95
Broasted Chicken
2pc. Dinner $13.95 / 4pc. Dinner $16.95
*Pork Chops
Broasted with light breading or charbroiled.
One-10oz. $11.95 / Two-10oz. $15.95

CHILDREN AND SENIOR MENU

*1/4 lb. Burger, Fries, Dessert
$5.95
3 Chicken Strips, Fries, Dessert
$5.95
1/4 lb. Hot Dog, Fries, Dessert
$5.95
Peanut Butter and Jelly, Fries, Dessert
$4.95
Combo Basket
1 chicken wing, 2 chicken strips, 4 cheeseballs, 2 mozzarella sticks, plus fries.
$6.95

SANDWICHES

All Burgers are Fresh Ground
*1/2 lb. Hamburger
$6.75
*1/2 lb. Cheeseburger
$7.25
*1/2 lb. Bacon Cheeseburger
$8.25
*1/2 lb. Swiss Mushroom Burger
$7.95
*Mike's Special - 1 lb. Double Burger
Extra Cheese - $0.50
$11.95
*Mike's Special - 1 lb. Double Bacon Cheeseburger
$13.95
*1/2 lb. Pizza Burger
$6.95
BLT
$6.95
1/4 lb. Hot Dog with Fries
$5.95
Chicken Breast
Grilled or breaded.
$6.95
BBQ Pork Sandwich with Slaw
$6.25
Philly Beef Sandwich

Shaved beef, cheese, peppers, onion, mushrooms, au jus.

$12.50
Grilled Cheese with Fries
$5.95
Grilled Ham and Cheese
$6.95
Fish Sandwich with Slaw and Fries
$9.95
Walleye Sandwich with Slaw and Fries
$10.95
Homemade Chicken Salad
$5.95
Breaded Pork Tenderloin
$6.75
*8 oz. Ribeye Sandwich

USDA Choice with grilled onions.

$13.95
*Prime Rib with Cheese, Grilled Onions and Peppers
$14.95
Crinkle Cut Fries with Sandwich
$1.75
Brew City Fries with Sandwich
$2.50

SOUPS

Cup of Soup
$2.95
Bowl of Soup
$3.95

CHILI-SEASONAL

Cup of Chili
$3.50
Bowl of Chili
$4.50
Add Cheese and Onion
$0.50

*Whether dining out of preparing food at home, consuming raw or undercooked hamburger, meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness.

Share by: